Fajr: There are two types of Fajr described by the Prophet (Salla Allah Alaihi Wa Sallam); Al-Fajr Al-Kathib (False Fajr) and Al-Fajr As-Sadiq (True Fajr).
Before the beginning of False Fajr (Zodiacal Light), the sky is completely dark. False Fajr appears in the East as a faint white light that looks like a big triangle whose base is on the horizon and summit is upward. The brightness of the False Fajr gets stronger as we approach the True Fajr.
As time goes by, the True Fajr (Astronomical Twilight) appears as a white light spread horizontally over the entire Eastern horizon. Note that at this time the False Fajr is still on and starts disappearing because of the brightness of the True Fajr. So there is a short overlap between the two Fajrs.
The True Fajr is distinguished from the False Fajr by its shape, where the False Fajr is vertical on the horizon, where as the True Fajr appears as a horizontal illumination on the horizon. In general the False Fajr appears 30-45 minutes before the True Fajr.
The observer should write down the time at which the False Fajr appears and the time at which the True Fajr appears.
Isha: After the sun sets, the sky continues to be illuminated in a similar way as it was before sunrise, and as time passes the sky will get darker until the illumination disappears, and this is the time of disappearance of the Ash-Safaq Al-Ahmar (Red Shafaq) or Sky Redness, which we believe is the Astronomical Twilight.
Isha time starts when the Red Shafaq disappears according to the most juristic methods (Maliki, Shafi’i and Hanbali). The only illumination that persists in the sky after the Red Shafaq disappearance is the White Shafaq (which we believe is the Zodiacal Twilight).
When comparing the Isha astronomical phenomenon with that of Fajr. The False Fajr corresponds to the White Shafaq disappearance and the True Fajr corresponds to the Red Shafaq disappearance
As such we believe that the manifestation of the disappearance of the Red Shafaq (shape and colors) is similar to that of the appearance of the True Fajr. Similarly, the manifestation of the False Fajr is similar to that of the disappearance of the White Shafaq.
Important Note: It should be highly noted that Red Shafaq does NOT mean the red color all the time because sometimes the sky is not red colored after sunset. Sometimes, the color of the sky after sunset is Yellow or Orange, and sometimes none of these colors appears after sunset. In this case the color of the sky graduates from blue to dark blue to navy blue then to black. As a conclusion, the color of the sky at the end of Red Shafaq is similar to its color at the beginning of the True Fajr. The only difference is that the True Fajr appears in East where as the Red Shafaq disappearance appears in West.